CMS US S&P 500Russell 1000 Earnings call · transcribed from the recording
CMS Energy (CMS) · Q3 2026 results and valuation
Share price: $69.62 · 2026-11-11
CMS Energy is an energy company operating in Michigan that provides electric and gas utility services. It also operates as an independent power producer and marketer of renewable energy. The company serves residential, commercial, and industrial customers in the Michigan area. Source: 10-K annual report (2026-02-10)
Results Q3 2026 vs Q2 2026 · previous quarter · published 27 Oct 2026 and 28 Jul 2026
Management sounded restrained, in its script and in answers to analysts.
1 · Numbers
—
Figures not yet filed
Outlook given
2 · How management spoke
Restrained
Less upbeat than 68% of company calls
Answers to analysts: cautious, in line with the script.
Similar to last call.
3 · What stood out
CMS reaffirmed its full-year 2026 guidance of $3.83 to $3.90 per share with confidence toward the high end.
Valuation
Is CMS Energy undervalued?
Reverse DCF on net income from the last full fiscal year (no meaningful free cash flow: a bank, insurer or a year of negative cash flow) (2025-12-31), grown for 10 years, discounted back, plus a terminal value. “Implied growth” is the rate the current price assumes.
The projected cash flow doesn't cover the debt, so the price is far above the model's fair value.
Current price
$69.62
close of 2026-11-11
Market implies growth of iThe yearly free-cash-flow growth, for the next 10 years, that today’s share price already assumes. If you believe the company grows faster than this, the stock is cheap under this model; slower, and it is expensive.
+16.9% for 10 yrs
Fair value / share
$-25.35
Buy below
$-19.01
Price vs fair value
n/a
Price vs buy-below price
n/a
Read between the lines
-
Guidance
CMS reaffirmed its full-year 2026 guidance of $3.83 to $3.90 per share with confidence toward the high end.
-
Figure
The company reported year-to-date adjusted net income of $915 million, or $2.95 per share, which is $0.29 favorable to last year and excludes restructuring activities at Northstar.
Source quote
“Year-to-date, the company delivered adjusted net income of $915 million, or $2.95 per share, which you'll note excludes the restructuring activities at Northstar, and is $0.29 favorable to last year.”
-
Figure
The IRP provides a capital investment opportunity of roughly $27 billion in new clean energy resources, battery storage, and gas generation.
Source quote
“In summary, our IRP provides significant capital investment opportunity of roughly $27 billion in new clean energy resources, battery storage, and gas generation.”
-
Figure
The commission approved a gas rate case order of $139 million, a 9.8% ROE, and a 50% equity ratio for the regulatory calendar.
Source quote
“As we turn to the regulatory calendar, I'll highlight the constructive order from the commission in our gas rate case approving $139 million or approximately 60% of our final ask, a 9.8% ROE, and 50% equity ratio.”
-
Figure
New rates, net of investment costs, resulted in a positive variance of 34 cents, with the benefits of last year's gas rate order, new electric rates from earlier this year, and continued investments in renewable…
Source quote
“New rates, net of investment costs, resulted in a positive variance of 34 cents, with the benefits of last year's gas rate order, new electric rates from earlier this year, and continued investments in renewable projects at the utility.”
3 more
-
Guidance
The company stated that the restructure is on target to be complete by year on.
-
Guidance
North Star is overperforming its planned guidance for the year.
-
Key theme
CMS expects some options to be pulled forward and will continue to have those options throughout the year.
Source quote
“Some of that will be pulled forward and we'll continue to have those options as we go through the year.”
Tone
How upbeat the language was, compared with other companiesiTone counts positive minus negative finance words, adjusted for length. Executives mostly speak positively, so the labels compare each call with every company's latest call: “typical” is the middle third, “very upbeat” the top tenth, “cautious” the bottom tenth.. Dot: Q3 2026. Ring: Q2 2026.
Script and answers carried a similar tone, so the script's message held up under questioning.
Sentences that drove the tone
“I continue to be proud with what the CMS Energy team has delivered and know that the benefit of growth flows to our customers as we spread fixed costs across...”
“For our investors, it delivers a premium total shareholder return made up of 6% to 8% adjusted EPS growth toward the high end, which reflects 7% or better, compounded annually,...”
“If I pull up from the details and reflect on the entire electric rate case, staff's position is constructive, a good starting point, and there are opportunities we'll pursue in...”
Full figures
Q3 2026 figures are not available yet: the company files its quarterly report (10-Q) a few weeks after the call. This page compares what management said; the figures are added when the report is filed.
Topics
Most discussed now
- New Reconciliations of these measures to the most directly comparable gap measures are included in the appendix and posted on CMS Energy's...
- New One, two, CMS Energy has talked about in terms of personal property tax and hundreds of millions of savings for customers and...
- Investment thesis because it is a durable and proven model that has delivered for more than 20 years of consistent...
- Longer term, CMS Energy continues to guide toward the high end of its adjusted EPS growth range of 6% to 8%.
- As CMS Energy has done in previous years, it will provide an update on its year-end call regarding the roll forward of...
Faded since Q2 2026
- Fading On the data center front, CMS Energy has made meaningful progress and have taken an additional step reaching an agreement under...
- Fading I'm going to share with you its plans to further simplify and strengthen its model as CMS Energy plans to...
- Fading CMS Energy's average residential electric customer could see approximately $7.50 per month of bill benefit with every gigawatt of...
- Dropped Following a comprehensive strategic review of NorthStar, CMS Energy is taking a deliberate step to simplify its business model and…
Latest announcements
Official filings, newest first. Summaries are generated from each filing and its attachment; every figure is checked against the source.
- Other events · SEC 8-K
- Results of operations; Regulation FD disclosure · SEC 8-K
CMS Energy reported adjusted earnings per share of $1.44 for the third quarter of 2026, compared to $0.93 in 2025.
- Results of operations; Regulation FD disclosure · SEC 8-K
CMS Energy reported diluted earnings per share of $0.37 for the second quarter of 2026, compared to $0.66 for the same period in 2025.
- Director or officer change; Regulation FD disclosure · SEC 8-K
CMS Energy appointed Sri Maddipati as Chief Financial Officer and Chris Fultz as President of Electric Supply, effective June 3, 2026, following the retirement of Rejji Hayes.
- Other events · SEC 8-K
- Articles or bylaws amended; Shareholder vote results · SEC 8-K · routine
- Results of operations; Regulation FD disclosure · SEC 8-K
CMS Energy reported diluted earnings per share of $1.10 for the first quarter of 2026, compared to $1.01 in the first quarter of 2025.
- Director or officer change · SEC 8-K
CMS Energy announced the appointment of Diane Leopold and Richard Keyes to the boards of directors of CMS Energy and Consumers Energy, effective February 20, 2026.
Catalyst calendar
management-stated targets — from the latest earnings call; plans, not promises.
-
after 2027
delivery of approximately 100% regulated utility earnings growth
Source quote
“and deliver approximately 100% regulated utility earnings growth after 2027.”
-
by year-end
completion of the restructuring
Source quote
“We are on track to complete the restructuring by year-end.”
-
beginning in 2031
financial compensation mechanism (FCM) of approximately $125 million
Source quote
“The IRP assumes a financial compensation mechanism, or FCM, of approximately $125 million beginning in 2031, growing to approximately $195 million by 2040, assuming a 50-50 ownership split.”
-
after the elections
further movement on the large data center project
Source quote
“That project continues to progress through zoning in multiple locations, and I expect further movement after the elections.”
-
late January
PFD position
Source quote
“We expect the PFD position in late January in a final order by early April of next year.”